Pet Insurance Fraud: A Growing Challenge

As pet insurance adoption accelerates across the U.S., so does the threat of fraud. Often overlooked compared to auto or health insurance, pet insurance fraud is becoming a critical issue—impacting costs, claim accuracy, and trust.

What Is Pet Insurance Fraud?

Pet insurance fraud involves intentionally providing false information to an insurer—either when applying for a policy or submitting a claim—with the goal of financial gain. It is a criminal offense and can be prosecuted as a felony in many states.

Common examples include:

• Submitting fake or inflated vet bills
• Claiming for treatments never received
• Filing multiple claims for the same expense
• Misrepresenting breed, age, or preexisting conditions
• Fraud can also originate from inside the clinic — such as exaggerated treatment costs or false documentation provided by staff.
  

A Growing Market, with Limited Safeguards

U.S. pet insurers are processing millions of claims per year, yet many still lack robust fraud detection tools. Compared to home or auto lines, the pet sector lags in data maturity and automated verification systems. Fraud detection often relies on manual spot checks or experience-based judgment.

As more people insure their pets—and more money moves through the system—opportunistic and organized fraud will increase unless addressed proactively.

What Can Be Done?

To reduce fraud risk, the industry must evolve:

• Introduce AI-powered claim review and text analysis
• Automate pre-policy validation of breed and medical history
• Use pattern detection and analytics to flag outliers
• Incorporate veterinary experts into fraud review workflows
• Invest in integrated systems that reduce reliance on manual documentation

The Bottom Line

Most pet owners and clinics are honest. But as the pet insurance market grows, insurers must take fraud seriously. Building better safeguards now is essential to protect policyholders, reduce premiums, and ensure legitimate claims are processed fairly.

‍